The tone of Nadine
Labaki’s “Where do we Go Now?” is for the most part comical and upbeat, which
is surprising considering it’s about the conflict between Muslims and
Christians in the Middle East. The movie takes place in a remote, unnamed
village in Lebanon, where both Christians and Muslim’s co exist with each
other. They’ve been at peace for some time now but all it can take is one
little feud to cause a bloody dispute.
As much as Labaki’s picture is about religious differences
the final conclusion I got from it is that: The men in this village are dumb,
aggressive babies who are incapable of solving their own disputes. After
hearing a report on the radio and television that an attack happened somewhere
else in the country resulting in a few Christian deaths, the woman in the
village cover the situation up the best they can, other wise the dissenting
religious men will fight and most likely kill one another. The graveyard
located outside of the village mostly contains men (husbands, brothers, sons etc.).
At one point someone remarks that the village has more dead than living. In an
odd way I was reminded of an episode of the “The Simpsons” in which Marge tries
to hide from Homer the fact that there is a Chili festival in Springfield
because she doesn’t want him to get drunk and make a fool of himself and her.
In order to cover up the situation the women try a number of
non-violent tactics. This is how the comic and upbeat-ness comes about. They
hire a group of young prostitutes to distract and tease the men, and later on
bake a bunch of hash and pills into baked goods to get them all stoned. I know,
I know these things seem more appropriate in an American teen stoner comedy,
but I must admit I somewhat enjoyed these little comic intervals. They give the
picture a sense of energy and vitality that’s unexpected. To add more comedy
there’s plenty of bickering amongst the townspeople and physical gags.
Now, I don’t have an issue with this picture’s negative view
on males but Lebaki and co screenwriter’s Rodney El Hadded, Jihad Hojeily and
Sam Mounier make every single man in the village, a dumb, aggressive baby. They
start out as caricatures and stay as them and because there’s no development
they eventually mold into one big blob of…dumb, aggressive, babies. The women
have to break up their fights and make them apologize to one another. I find it
difficult to believe that there wouldn’t at least be one man smart enough to
see the stupidity and work with the women.
Labaki and her writers make a worthy effort with “Where Do
We Go Now?” The acting (which includes Labaki herself in a leading role) is
decent enough, although none of the performances, even those of the females,
are all that memorable. And I applaud their attempt at trying to present a
serious issue in a comic light (even though there are peculiar shifts in mood
and emotion, from funny, to sad, to funny again). But in the end the movie has
a too narrow and bitter view of its men. We’re not all dumb, aggressive babies.
2.5/4
No comments:
Post a Comment